Monday-Friday, 8:30 a.m.-5:00 p.m. EST

Call Our Main Line for 24-Hour Service.

Local Insurance Agents Focus on You

Our team at the James F. Sutton Agency is experienced and dedicated. We live and work on Long Island and consider you our neighbor. Our knowledgeable independent insurance agents will consult with you to determine which insurance solutions are best for your family or your business. Our responsive agency staff will answer your questions and handle the details on your behalf.

If you know the person you need to reach, use the staff directory below. Or, simply contact our Long Island office, and you will be directed to the appropriate area.

Meet Dedicated Independent Insurance Agents in Long Island

Welcome to James F. Sutton Agency, where we have an experienced team of independent insurance agents in Long Island, entirely dedicated to providing personalized service and comprehensive coverage tailored to meet your needs.

A family is sprawled on the grass in a park, sharing laughter and moments in the sun

Expertise You Can Trust

Our agents are highly knowledgeable about the various insurance products we offer. They work closely with our clients to navigate the available options and find the best policies from the insurance companies we represent on Long Island. Our goal is to help you feel confident in your insurance choices, whether you’re seeking home, auto, or business protection.

A Commitment to Client Relationships

What sets us apart from other insurance agencies is our unwavering commitment to client satisfaction. We believe in building lasting relationships with our clients, understanding their unique needs, and providing proactive support at every stage of their insurance journey. As your local independent insurance agent, we empower you with accurate information and options.

Our Mission

Our mission is to provide the highest level of service while connecting you with the best available insurance coverage. We want to be your trusted advisor in the ever-evolving world of insurance, working with you closely as you seek the best coverage for you and your family.

Get in Touch

As an independent insurance agency in Long Island, we work on translating complexity to clarity so that you can secure dependable insurance protection. Contact us today and we’ll help you safeguard what matters most to you.

Our Team

User placeholder

James D. Sutton, CPCU, CIC

Chairman

User placeholder

James R. Sutton

President

User placeholder

Jean Sharpe, AAI-M, CPIA

Comptroller/ Life & Health

User placeholder

Robert A. Messina, CIC, AIS, AAI

Vice President and Personal Lines Manager

User placeholder

Sherri Koos

Personal Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Jill Milone

P.L. Account Manager

User placeholder

Teresa Firth

Personal Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Patrice Gambino

Personal Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Vikki Deall

Personal Lines Assistant Account Manager

User placeholder

Patricia Dirla

P.L. Assistant

User placeholder

Michele Berry

Personal Lines

User placeholder

Ryan D. Gillies

Producer

User placeholder

Elbert Butts

Producer

User placeholder

Jeff Flamman

Financial Services

User placeholder

Ed Weidler, CPCU

Commercial Lines Manager

User placeholder

Marion Muhr

Commercial Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Matthew R. Rowsell, AAI, CLCS, CPIA

Commercial Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Susan OBraitis

Commercial Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

Ashley Zemaitis

Commercial Lines Account Manager

User placeholder

 Lynn Onken

Commercial Lines Assistant

User placeholder

Kristi Tunick

Producer

User placeholder

Meaghan Sutton

Billing Dept

User placeholder

Susan Moloney

Reception