Insurance Companies You Trust, Service You Count On
Working with an independent insurance agency is about choice. We’re proud of the choices we provide our valued customers, starting with the reputable insurance companies we represent. Our agency only works with highly rated companies that share our commitment to delivering quality products and timely service. We seek competitive quotes from multiple national and New York companies on your behalf. You can rest assured the insurance rate you pay is the best possible rate for insurance you need.
Furthermore, the insurance companies we work with can offer immediate assistance with any billing or payment questions you may have. Most of the companies we represent offer the convenience of online bill pay either with an electronic check or credit/debit card.
In the event of a claim, trust the James F. Sutton Agency to ensure your claim is processed promptly and efficiently. For claims assistance, you may choose to contact the insurance company directly from the list below.
In addition to the following list, we offer coverage with Fidelity and Statewide. Feel free to contact our experienced customer service professionals, who can guide you through the process.
Independent. Experienced. Uncompromising in Our Commitment to You.
Choosing an independent insurance agency means choosing advocacy, access, and tailored expertise. At the James F. Sutton Insurance Agency, we take pride in offering our clients the benefit of choice—backed by decades of industry insight and trusted partnerships with top-rated regional and national carriers.
We represent only insurers known for their financial strength, product excellence, and consistent service standards—organizations that reflect our own values of integrity and reliability. This independence allows us to source multiple competitive quotes on your behalf, ensuring that your coverage is both comprehensive and cost-effective.
In addition to personalized support from our team, our carrier partners offer convenient resources such as secure online billing, payment options, and dedicated claims support. For your convenience, direct contact information for servicing, billing inquiries, and claims reporting is listed below—should you ever wish to connect with your insurer directly.
And as always, our agency remains at your side—ready to assist, advocate, and ensure your experience is handled with the highest level of care and professionalism.
Our Network of Insurance Carriers
AmTrust
Billing and Customer Service: 877-528-7878
Claims For Workers Comp: 775-908-3724
Claims for All other policies: 877-207-3961
Chubb
800-248-2270 for service
800-884-3770 option 1, option 1 for billing
800-252-4670 option 1 for claims
Hartford
800-771-8557 option 3 for service
866-581-5039 for billing
800-243-5860 option 1 for claims
Kingstone Insurance
Service: 800-364-7045 option 5
Billing: 800-364-7045 option 2
Claims: 800-364-7045 option 2
Merchants Insurance Group
Service: 800-462-1077
Billing: 800-462-1077 option 1
Claims: 800-952-5246 opt 1
Our Network of Insurance Companies
Foremost
Customer Service: (800) 527-3905
Billing: (888) 888-0080
Claims: (800) 527-3907
Website
Report a Claim
Harleysville Insurance
Customer Service: (800) 338-8301
Billing: (866) 665-4992
Claims: (800) 892-8877