Contact Our Long Island Insurance Agency

You don’t build a successful Long Island business over 50 years without being responsive to customers. The James F. Sutton Agency is dedicated to giving you the best service possible. We welcome any questions, comments and suggestions you may have.

Business owners rely on us to consult with them on insurance solutions so they can focus on running their operation. Individuals and families look to our independent insurance agents for auto, home and life insurance. We seek competitive quotes from multiple insurance companies, which saves you time and money.

Contact us via email by completing the easy form here. Our staff will be in touch as soon as possible to answer your questions and proceed with an insurance quote or, if necessary, file a claim on an existing policy.

James F. Sutton Agency, Ltd.

143 – 149 East Main Street
East Islip, NY 11730

Phone: 631-581-7978
Fax: 631-581-7507 

Map & Directions