Local Insurance Agents Focus on You

The team at James F. Sutton Insurance Agency is experienced and dedicated. We live and work on Long Island and consider you our neighbor. Our knowledgeable independent insurance agents will consult with you to determine which insurance solutions are best for your family or your business. Our responsive agency staff will answer your questions and handle the details on your behalf.

If you know the person you need to reach, use the staff directory below. Or simply contact our Long Island office and you will be directed to the appropriate area.

  • James D. Sutton, CPCU, CIC
    President
    (631) 446-3165
  • Jean Sharpe, CPIA
    Comptroller, Life & Health
    (631) 446-3177
  • Robert A. Messina, CIC, AIS, AAI
    P.L. Manager
    (631) 446-3166
  • Sherri Koos
    P.L. Account Manager
    (631) 446-3172
  • Laura Senn, CIC
    P.L. Account Manager
    (631) 446-3173
  • Teresa Firth
    P.L. Account Manager
    (631) 446-3170
  • Vikki Deall
    P.L. Assistant Account manager
    (631) 446-3171
  • Patricia Dirla
    P.L. Assistant
    (631) 446-3168
  • Michele Berry
    P.L. Sales
    (631) 446-3167
  • Ryan D. Gillies
    P.L. Sales
    (631) 446-3169
  • Jeff Flamman
    Life & Health
    (631) 446-3175
  • Ed Weidler, CPCU
    C.L. Manager
    (631) 446-3179
  • Guy Colombo
    C.L. Account Manager
    (631) 446-3180
  • Matthew R. Rowsell, AAI, CLCS, CPIA
    C.L. Assistant Manager/Sales
    (631) 446-3174
  • Susan Obraitis
    C.L. Account Manager/Sales
    (631) 446-3176
  • James R. Sutton
    Producer
    (631) 446-3171
  • Kristi Tunick
    Producer
    (631) 446-3182